Six (and one likely future) Hall of Famers are among those honored with the retirement uniform #5. We also have our first executive, Carl Barger, whose favorite player was Dimaggio, prompting the Marlins to retire #5 in his honor. There was also one non-Hall of Famer, one of the most tragic stories in sports.
Willard Hershberger, Cincinnati Reds
The backup to Hall of Fame catcher Ernie Lombardi, Hershberger was filling in for the injured “Schnozz” in July 1940. After the Reds lost games to inferior teams, Hershberger blamed himself and either said or implied that he would commit suicide like his father. Manager Bill McKenchie spoke with the catcher, and believed he was better at the end of their conversation. The next day, however, he was found dead in the hotel bathtub from a slashed throat.
Following his death, #5 was temporarily retired until 1942. In 1967 the greatest catcher in big league history wore the number, and it was retired permanently in 1986.
Johnny Bench, Cincinnati Reds
Brooks Robinson, Baltimore Orioles
Carl Barger, Florida Marlins
George Brett, Kansas City Royals
Hank Greenberg, Detroit Tigers
Jeff Bagwell, Hosuton Astros
Joe DiMaggio, New York Yankees
Lou Boudreau, Cleveland Indians