Blog Archives

1986 Fleer is bland

I tried coming up with a witty title, but I just couldn’t do it. 1986 Fleer is so bland it caused my brain to freeze up when I tried to be creative. So there you have it. 1986 Fleer is bland. That’s not to say it isn’t without its charm.

McGaffigan bunting

Look at that. A pitcher at the plate. Bunting. How quaint. Andy McGaffigan spent time with the Yankees, Giants, and Expos before coming to the Reds in 1984. By the time this card was released, he was back in Montreal.

Want to see another charming card?

Rose and Gooden

How about a fella nearing the end of his amazing career, and another just starting what many thought would be equally amazing? Pete Rose eclipsed Ty Cobb‘s hits record in 1985, and Dwight Gooden became the youngest pitcher ever to win twenty games in a season. If you didn’t know those two facts, you can just flip the card over…

Rose and Gooden

…and BOOM! Knowledge. Ironically, I don’t think Fleer used the word ironically correctly.

Fleer was very busy in 1986. In addition to the regular base set, there were at least six boxed sets that included Reds. The bland brand released their third Update set at the end of the year, which included rookies Kurt Stillwell and Tracy Jones and veterans Bill Gullickson and John Denny. They also released a 120-card mini set which was not a parallel of base set cards but featured different photos. What a novel idea.

Then there was the 132-card Star Sticker set. I actually bought a wax box of these a few years ago and had a blast ripping the packs, but fell 32 cards short on completing the entire set.


Tom Browning popped up in a lot of 1986 sets, and for good reason. His 1985 rookie campaign was overshadowed by the St. Louis speedster Vince Coleman, but Browning was the first rookie since the 1960s to win 20 games in a season. Not Dwight Gooden. Tom Browning. And no rookie pitcher has done it since. I realize wins are not really in vogue when talking about pitcher stats, but 20 wins is still a big deal in my mind. Coleman captured all 24 first-place votes for 1985 Rookie of the Year, and I have to admit that I’m a little perturbed at the Cincinnati BBWAA voters for that.

Fleer also released a handful of smaller box sets. I do not have any of the 1986 Fleer League Leaders cards, and I’m not sure I’ve ever actually seen one in person. There are two Reds in the set, Dave Parker and Pete Rose. The relatively new List of Fisk blog breaks down Carlton Fisk‘s card in the set.

Another box set was called “Limited Edition.”

Limited Edition

How limited, you ask? Probably not very. It was 1986 after all and this set is not terribly difficult to track down 32 years later. Again, there are two Reds in the set and again, it’s Parker and Rose. I haven’t gone to the trouble of finding the Rose card yet and I have no idea how long Parker has been in my collection.

Another box set was Fleer’s “Baseball’s Best” (but usually listed in price guides as “Sluggers/Pitchers”). Again, 44 cards.


Parker didn’t make the cut for this set, but Rose did, even though he could hardly be called a “Slugger.” Browning and Mario Soto were included among the pitchers. I like this particular set because of the consistency of it. Fleer released this set from 1986 through 1988 with the border being the only major change in the design.

Two other 1986 Fleer Reds cards I don’t have were inserts into packs: “Future Hall of Famers” (Rose) and “All-Stars” (Parker). Both of these inserts are more attractive than the base set design. Which isn’t saying a whole lot, because, you know, 1986 Fleer is bland.

Talk about Bad Wax!

Note: This post is dedicated to Mike at Awesomely Bad Wax Packs.

I bought a box of 1986 Fleer “Star Stickers.” 36 packs in the box, 5 cards in each pack (plus a team logo sticker with “Baseball’s Famous Feats” on the reverse). That comes out to 180 cards total. With a 132-card set, I figure I stand a good shot at completing the set, and if not, I’ll need to track down at most five cards. Boy, was I wrong.

I need more than five. More than ten. More than twenty. More than thirty. Out of those 180 cards, I only got 100 different cards…falling 32 cards short of the set. To make matters worse, two of the packs had doubles in the pack. The first occurrence was not that terrible, since it was Dave Parker in a Reds uniform. One for the set, one for my collection, and one for my son. The second double-in-a-single-pack however, was a travesty. Andre Thornton. Andre who??? Not Dawson, Thornton. It would not have been so bad if I had completed the set, but I’m 32 cards short with 80 duplicates!

To make matters worse, I couldn’t even complete the 22-card “Baseball’s Famous Feats” set on the reverse of the team stickers. There’s one in each of 36 packs, and I’m three lousy “Feats” short!

Click here to see what I need, and if you could help I would appreciate it very much. When I have some time off from work I will post a message over The Bench, but for some reason I can’t log on there at work.

Man, I hope my experience with 1988 Topps Big is better.

%d bloggers like this: