The 50 Greatest Players in St. Louis Cardinals History by Robert W. Cohen (2015)
The 50 Greatest Players in St. Louis Cardinals History
by Robert W. Cohen
Taylor Trade Publishing, 2015
Every baseball team with a substantial amount of history behind it has those players who are undeniably great. Usually the top five or ten players can be generally agreed upon, even if the order of ranking them causes some debate among fans. The Yankees lay claim to Ruth, Gehrig, and DiMaggio. The Reds rest on Bench, Rose, and Robinson. Boston boasts Williams and Yaz. The Pirates, Clemente and Stargell. Likewise, the St. Louis Cardinals have their fair share of all-time greats, including Stan Musial, Rogers Hornsby, Albert Pujols, and Bob Gibson.
The further down the list you go, though, discussions become more heated and forgotten stars of the past are brought back into the spotlight. Robert W. Cohen presents a case for his rankings in The 50 Greatest Players in St. Louis Cardinals History, referencing a player’s season-by-season dominance in the league, as well as their statistical fortitude when compared to other Cardinals throughout history. Only a player’s time with St. Louis is considered in the rankings, but Cohen does not ignore their contributions to other teams in his short biographical sketches.
Everyone who has been inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame with a Cardinals cap on the plaque is mentioned, and ranks highly in Cohen’s book. There are also players whose Hall of Fame cases were built in other cities, such as Steve Carlton and Orlando Cepeda, but their contributions as Cardinals were significant enough to warrant inclusion among the top fifty. Vince Coleman, Willie McGee, John Tudor, Edgar Renteria, and Terry Pendleton are just a few of the other names included among the fifty best.
Cohen’s style is a bit dry, relying on statistics to tell the narrative rather than examples of why the players should be considered. There are exceptions to this, such as the case of Joaquin Andujar, who checks in at number forty-nine. The author displays Andujar’s eccentricity through quotes such as, “You can’t worry if it’s cold; you can’t worry if it’s hot; you only worry if you get sick. Because then, if you don’t get well, you die.”
The 50 Greatest Players in St. Louis Cardinals History is well-researched and informative, and Cardinals fans will enjoy it. Readers whose fandom lies elsewhere, however, might struggle to make it through some of the chapters that lack entertaining anecdotes.
Posted on May 15, 2015, in baseball, books, reviews and tagged Robert W. Cohen, St. Louis Cardinals, Taylor Trade Publishing, The 50 Greatest Players in St. Louis Cardinals History. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.