Starting pitchers and the Hall of Fame

Did you realize there are no starting pitchers in the Hall of Fame that debuted after 1967? Tom Seaver, Nolan Ryan, Catfish Hunter…they all started their careers in the 1960s. If Bert Blyleven makes it this year (which he should), then he would be the newest starter in the Hall by debut date…1970. The only other starting pitchers who have received more than 5% of the vote in recent years are Jack Morris and Tommy John (who started in 1963). John’s last year of eligibility was 2009, while Morris received 50% support last year for the first time in 11 years on the ballot. By comparison, Blyleven climbed to 50% by his ninth year on the ballot.

Recent pitchers who have appeared on the ballot include Dwight Gooden, Mark Langston, Bret Saberhagen, David Cone, Todd Stottlemyre, Jose Rijo, and Chuck Finley. None of them received enough votes to stay on the ballot a second year. I was a little surprised that Cone didn’t get more support (21 votes for 3.9%), but I never expected him to get in either. Even Orel Hershiser, who won 204 games, only lasted two years on the ballot (dropping from 11.2% in 2006 to 4.4% in 2007). That’s better than 245-game winner Dennis Martinez, who was one-and-done with 3.2% in 2004.

In 2011, only a few starters will be on the ballot for the first time, the most interesting being Kevin Brown. Brown won 211 games in his career, but was named in the Mitchell Report. If McGwire–who was perceived as a shoo-in for Cooperstown before the steroid scandal–only receives 25% of the vote, then I see a possibility of one-and-done for a borderline candidate like Brown. The only other pitcher with more than 150 wins on the 2011 ballot is Al Leiter, but despite his consistency I don’t expect him to receive much support for the Hall of Fame.

200-game winners on the ballot down the road…
2012: nobody
2013: Roger Clemens, Curt Schilling, David Wells
2014: Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine, Mike Mussina, Kenny Rogers
2015: Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, John Smoltz

Of those, I expect six (maybe seven) to get inducted. The earliest debut of those six is Maddux in 1986. If Blyleven gets in, and Morris doesn’t, that still leaves a 16-year gap of no new starting pitchers in the Hall of Fame.

Does this seem strange to anyone else?

* Addendum…completely slipping my mind when I wrote this post was Dennis Eckersley, who began his major league career in 1975. Though he never would have made it to Cooperstown had he not moved to the bullpen and dominated in the late 1980s with Oakland, the first half of his career as a starting pitcher wasn’t a total wash: 151 W-128 L, 3.67 ERA, 111 ERA+, and 42.1 WAR.


5 thoughts on “Starting pitchers and the Hall of Fame”

  1. That does seem odd.
    I do love a good HOF discussion though.
    I am more of an HOF elitist. I don’t like that a player could get in, because the rest of the possibilities are weak. If Blyleven deserves to get in, he should get in, regardless of the rest of the possibilities. I know there is a numerical limit, based on ballots, etc, but I don’t think it has ever been reached. Okay, I’ll get off of my soapbox.

  2. Roger Clemens debuted in 1984 and he belongs in the HOF, he was a clear HOFer before the HGH…..very possibly the greatest pitcher in the history of baseball, in my opiinion one of the two dominating pichers of the modern era, the other is Grove.

    The exceptions I see are Rogers, Wells because of personlality issues and maybe Schilling )same reasons although Boomer was much more obnoxious, Tthe others deserve to be anbd should be in the HOF,

  3. It’s a slippery slope with Clemens…let one in, it’s easier to let the rest (McGwire, Palmeiro). I don’t think Rogers stands a chance, his stats pale in comparison to Maddux and Glavine, but I don’t think he would have much of a shot even without them on the same ballot.

  4. Blyleven was such a jerk (still is), he’ll never get in. Voters have always had a “big season” bias. Hunter, Drysdale, Tiant and Pappas all have very similar lifetime stats. Which two got in? The two with the Cy Youngs and big seasons.

    Schilling will get in for this reason. Saberhagen may, as well. He had a Koufax type career.

    As far as Clemens… they will make him wait a few season, but he’s going in. He pitched for both Boston and the Yankees. The east coast bias will help him in the long run.

This is where you talk...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.